I guess the alu steerer is lighter but does that means its weaker? And if so is the trade-off worth it? Obviously if I can get a lighter fork great, but I dont want to compromise strength too much.
both aluminium alloy and steel steerers have to be made strong enough with regards to fork safety, so both are rated at same strength
the aluminium alloy is lighter, but uses thicker wall to attain the same strength, but overall little lighter than the cromoly steel steerer.
Coil vs air - any feedback on this? I assume air is good for the adjustability and to save weight. But how is the ride feel? And is it less durable? Air shocks always seem to leak in my experience.
personal choice, air is infinitely adjustable so easier to get it "spot on" for your body weight, riding style and as your body weight changes across the season…
coil can feel better on smaller bumps, unless you have a big air volume on forks like Totems (internal air space is larger so runs at lower pressure)
Pikes with coil or air feel damn good, so make your choice, i have not found / seen the air fork to be less durable….all forks need loving!
Mythic / Da Kine / Esher Shore / Freeborn
http://hampsteadbandit.blogspot.com/