Normally, I wouldn’t respond to any online forum but in this instance I have to get my points across.
Firstly, there is absolutely no danger to my child here whatsoever. I know the limits of my bike and the terrain. I will never ride a skinny or do any jump or drop with my children. That is risk to my child, at least with my riding ability on these features. With the trails I choose to ride, I am confident in my ability and there is no more risk for my child than hiking. There is a large gap between the stem and his seat, if he falls he will fall into that gap, he will not go over the bars which is the most dangerous thing that could happen. Also, there is no chance of him falling to the sides as my arms will protect him from falling off. His foot can not go into the front wheel, he is wearing shoes that restrict this and his legs aren't long enough. The upper limit of trails to be ridden for me are Expresso, John Deer and Gear Jammer on Burnaby Mountain. Will my child face fear? Of course he will, as you can see in this video. In 3.5 years of riding on the shotgun seat, neither of my 2 kids has ever gone over the bars.
Secondly, I have 2 kids and they absolutely love riding on the shotgun seat. There are times when my child will walk up and sit on the shotgun seat begging me to take him for a ride. The viewer here only has a very limited view of what my child is experiencing, they are watching my child in a hyper focused state. I haven’t shared with the viewer when we are paused on the trail and my kids are demanding to be put back on the seat and they are asking me to ride faster.
Thirdly, I have never ever had 1 negative experience on any mountain with any hiker or mountain biker watching me ride with the shotgun seat. Between the rides with my 2 kids on the shotgun seat, I would estimate that I have passed at least 500-750 hikers & mountain bikers over the past 3.5 years since I have been riding with the shotgun seat. I have always been met with smiles and encouragement from both hikers and mountain bikers alike. It is very easy to sit in front of the keyboard and criticize me as a parent, I understand this and it doesn’t bother me at all. I already know that people will pick and choose and criticize, that is what the internet breeds unfortunately.
Fourthly, let’s talk about hyper fragility with kids. This is very common nowadays with kids encouraged to not be exposed to any risk whatsoever. Kids are resilient, go talk to a paediatrician or an orthopaedic surgeon. They will tell you how resilient kids are and many will tell you that kids are made of rubber. Kids fall, cry for 10 minutes and then get up and continue doing whatever sport they are doing. Kids have always been this way, it’s only modern society that is hyper fragile and coddles the child. I’ve carefully assessed all risks on every feature and ride only when I am certain that my kid will be safe.
Fifth point, what my child learns from this experience, seeing me climb up the trail, assess risks, progress in my riding with him is much more valuable and more important to me as a parent and for his overall development than the minimum risk that he may face.
Finally, MY KIDS MY RULES. I thank all of you for your parenting advice and criticisms.