A different point of view: a false economy created by a situation that should have never occurred is now receding back to normal levels. It's quite possible that those jobs would not have existed if BC RE wasn't flooded by foreign investment. BC's problem is that its economy isn't diversified enough.
Anyways, the article in question is only posing a hypothesis. No real data linking the two.
A different point of view: a false economy created by a situation that should have never occurred is now receding back to normal levels. It's quite possible that those jobs would not have existed if BC RE wasn't flooded by foreign investment. BC's problem is that its economy isn't diversified enough.
Anyways, the article in question is only posing a hypothesis. No real data linking the two.
This. Yeah there is going to be hurt in the home construction/reno business (and I have friends in it who I feel for) but continuing on the current path would have just led to bigger hurt in the long term. The bigger you let the bubble inflate, the harder the landing. Real estate as a % of GDP is already way waaaay out of historical norms in BC and Canada and it's not healthy.
This. Yeah there is going to be hurt in the home construction/reno business (and I have friends in it who I feel for) but continuing on the current path would have just led to bigger hurt in the long term. The bigger you let the bubble inflate, the harder the landing. Real estate as a % of GDP is already way waaaay out of historical norms in BC and Canada and it's not healthy.
Worse comes to worse, we'll just ditch our skill set with wood and concrete, and move towards developing a new trade skill on steel pipelines instead…
Oh… Canada…
"The countryâs strongest economy, British Columbia, shed 9,300 positions, mostly in the services-producing sector. The losses come after the provincial government imposed a tax on foreign housing buyers in an attempt to thwart real estate speculators and cool the housing market. Although the tax has curbed housing sales, it is unknown whether the slowdown was responsible for Novemberâs losses or if it would lead to further declines."
Ok, so job losses 1: affordability 0.
Careful what we ask for, right?
1) Anyone here know someone who can suddenly get into the market now that there's this tax?
2) Anyone here know someone who works in housing construction, real estate or related services that has lost their job or has less work?
If we're only saying 'yes' to #2..what's been achieved here?
This tax is feeling like a Populist measure, akin to claiming of putting mfgr jobs back in the Rust Belt states.
Time will judge this move. We've already judged decision makers for not doing it sooner. So the question becomes: is it better late than never, or meaningless for the well-being of those not directly-exposed to this tax?
Full article here: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/economy/jobs/canadian-employment-report/article33132064/
wait so are you really expecting the prices to have reset so fast that locals could buy already ??
the one thing i CAN def tell you that has occured is in richmond, were EVERY for sale sign also had a SOLD sticker on it the second the post was planted no longer is the case… there are tons of actual for sale signs…
and my mailbox is no longer flooded with chinese real estate co flyers written in only chinese..
so yea im fukn ecstatic about the tax…. keep it coming, and maybe just maybe locals will finaly be able to live and stay here..
Worse comes to worse, we'll just ditch our skill set with wood and concrete, and move towards developing a new trade skill on steel pipelines instead…
Oh… Canada…
Diversification is the answer. Hedging your bets on one source of revenue is a risky move no matter the source.
My brother is a project manager for a small developer. He said there was a shortage of tradesmen/women to fulfill the demand to the point that the people being hired and the work being done was of questionable quality. If demand drops, I don't think the impact will be as catastrophic as some will cry it to be.
Diversification is the answer. Hedging your bets on one source of revenue is a risky move no matter the source.
My brother is a project manager for a small developer. He said there was a shortage of tradesmen/women to fulfill the demand to the point that the people being hired and the work being done was of questionable quality. If demand drops, I don't think the impact will be as catastrophic as some will cry it to be.
I've seen this first hand myself. The quality of trades people have taken a huge dive. The industry needs to slow down abit, to return to a higher level of proficiency.
"X is for x-ray. If you've been bikin' and you haven't had an x-ray, you ain't goin' hard enough." - Bob Roll
wait so are you really expecting the prices to have reset so fast that locals could buy already ??
the one thing i CAN def tell you that has occured is in richmond, were EVERY for sale sign also had a SOLD sticker on it the second the post was planted no longer is the case… there are tons of actual for sale signs…
and my mailbox is no longer flooded with chinese real estate co flyers written in only chinese..
so yea im fukn ecstatic about the tax…. keep it coming, and maybe just maybe locals will finaly be able to live and stay here..
The realtor's are calling for 7.8% price decline in Vancouver prices next year. Does that make all the difference RE: affordability?
NSMBA member.
Prices finally dropping?
They keep finding new ways to appease their biggest party donors.
Its going to take a generation for prices to normalize. Interest rates have begun their long steady grind upwards which could take a decade. Add in people locking in mortgages for 5 years at a time, the current crop of people locked out of the housing market due to these stupid prices are in purgatory.
Those that didn't sell 6 months ago missed out on a lottery. But i get it, its a hassle to sell and cash out then have to find a new place and deal with the unknowns.
WTF! we dont need more measures to access cheap money! What a contradiction - force people to qualify at higher rates limiting the amount you can borrow, and then now this - helping poor people who cant save enough for a down payment to get in the market.
And us the taxpayer is flipping the bill for the interest free loan. Unbelievably stupid.
Prices finally dropping?
wow that's quite something. Prices across BC probably just went up %10+ when that hit the press, houses for everyone! I wonder if I can retroactively apply for this thing after sweating my ass off for years to save for a down payment..lol.
I'm predicting a massive economic crisis in 5 years time when everyone who jumped on board realizes they actually, you know, have to pay back this loan.
Why would the government give out loans for down payments? Isn't the fundamental point of a down payment to prove (to yourself, and to the bank) that you will be able to pay your mortgage?
They keep finding new ways to appease their biggest party donors.
This +10000000
This announcement is a combination of a few things … the confirmation that BC's GDP is in large part driven by real estate and construction, that the Liberal party donors call the shots, and that there's an election coming up next spring.
:canada: :england:
I'm predicting a massive economic crisis in 5 years time when everyone who jumped on board realizes they actually, you know, have to pay back this loan.
That's the first thing I thought… it sets up a false economy where people think that they can afford it, but then the bill comes due, likely at the same time they'll be renewing their mortgage at a higher rate, and then the cash flow reality hits.
Forum jump:
