Most guys with your job are still using full size GM's up here,cause they're reliable and comfortable to drive.
I have a Canyon - quad cab - off road package. It was $500 less than the equivalent full sized Sierra (fleet pricing). Also, the older full sized Chevy and GMC trucks had better gas mileage than the old model Canyon / Colorado (mine is a 2011).
Having said that, I had a Colorado before the Canyon, and other than minor little things both have been flawless.
Minor little things have included the odd sensor needing replacement (warranty work), some trim that needed re-gluing (warranty work) and oil changes.
I have driven both trucks to Mt. Cain on the north island many, many times. The access road is a not very well maintained logging road that is (gasp) covered in snow much of the ski season. I have not been easy on either truck.
The whole "Toyota's are more reliable" thing is mostly marketing and market "faith". The reality is that GM and Chev have been reliable all along - they just don't hold their used value as well.
Which leads me to my conclusion - a used GMC Canyon is probably the best deal out there.
I will get a diesel next time around - the gasmileage on my Canyon is pathetic…13 l / 100 km highway using "supercruiser" techniques.
And yes - fits up to 6 AM bikes in the back with the tail-gate up.
Only really sits 5 adults - and that's stuffed in…
I have 21,474,850 rep points...
My blog - read it!
http://www.citizenclass.ca