Thanks for all the input guys. Going to do some more Buell research and then make a decision from there.
What made you get rid of it Dave? 10 000 is spooky early. Wonder if this is common? I always thought the sportster motors were fairly reliable by Harley standards. Especially the 1200's. Would you do it again?
I wanted something a bit more hardcore sportbike and bought a Suzuki TL1000R. I love the power delivery of the big twins.
My memory may be off, it was 10 years ago and the number may have been 16000k (10k miles) but still it's fairly early. Yes the sporty twins are reliable, the bottom ends and trannies are pretty solid but the top ends weren't really designed to take the higher revs that a sport bike uses. The good thing about it all is top end rebuilds are pretty simple, and if your good at this sort of thing (which it sounds like you are) you could do it yourself. The Harley/Buell relationship is closer than just the parts. It's a bike that has soul, one of those things that you tinker and play with, polish and clean.
Would I do it again….yes probably. The newer Buells use an new powerplant.
If you want to know everything there is to know about Buell, old and new, stop in at Trev Deeley and ask for Stuart Wells. He's an awesome guy and has been with Buell since the beginning. Say hi for me too, I haven't seen him in too many years.