I would echo many opinions here by saying do NOT buy a downhill bike!
Downhill bikes are purpose-built for a pretty specific task. Buy a bike with 150 - 160mm of travel and a full range of gears and you will have a bike that can do everything quite well. Sure, you'll have fun on either, but you'll have a lot more fun on a 160mm bike that pedals well too. The "all mountain" or "trail" bike with 6" travel will better suit 95% of your riding.
Also, a 160mm bike will serve you well at Whistler if you are not an expert or better rider. I plan to put at least 10 park days in this year on my 160mm travel bike and look forward to it!