Crank Bros Mallet E Pedals

Words Pete Roggeman
Photos Kaz Yamamura
Date Feb 21, 2016
crankbrothers_mallet_3

The Crank Brothers Mallet E is definitely a looker. Photo: Cam McRae

Crank Brothers pedal fans rejoice: the new Mallet E, aimed at the ‘Enduro’ market (sigh) is the best kind of compromise. Similar in appearance to the popular Mallet DH, the Mallet E was built for rides that include pedaling up, across, over, and down. Some people who obsess over labels call that Enduro but crusty old fuckers like me just call that mountain biking.
CrankBrothersMallet_NSMB_KYamamura-8

The Crank Bros Mallet E’s body design features chamfered leading edges to reduce the jarring impact of pedal strikes. Photo: Kaz Yamamura

What refinements? The Crank Brothers Mallet E is 12% smaller than the Mallet DH, providing better lateral clearance. Your foot also sits 5mm closer to the bike on either side – and that narrower Q factor is a good indicator of the different intention for this pedal. Chamfered leading edges help pedal strikes deflect and trundle along, instead of hanging up on whatever caused your latest gumby moment.
CrankBrothersMallet_NSMB_KYamamura-5

Traction pads on either side of the body are more noticeable for their impact on clip-in feel than for actual traction. I started with the higher 2mm pad and found engagement to be a bit vague. Slide ’em out and switch to the 1mm pad the difference was a noticeable improvement. Photo: Kaz Yamamura

They also have a surprisingly noticeable adjustable traction pad on either end of the axle where the body contacts the bottom of your shoe allows you to dial in shoe sole/pedal body spacing. The variation is only 1mm of vertical height but, depending on your kicks, that can make the difference between a vague feeling clip-in and a solid one. Not as solid a feeling as an SPD, however that’s what you get with Crank Brothers: extra float and a softer feel, thanks to the brass cleats and unique interface. If you know it and like it, the Mallet E won’t be a surprise, and you’ll be content. If you’re used to the well-defined in/out of an SPD, it’ll be an adjustment.
crankbrothers_mallet_2

Here’s a good look at the higher traction pad. See how it protrudes? With the Northwave Explorers I’m testing, that was a bit too much. The lower traction pad allowed for a better engagement and I can feel the platform under my feet when I push hard. The pins are gravy especially in our current conditions. Photo: Cam McRae

So it was for me. After a few weeks’ worth of use on the shore, I took them along to Chile for the launch of the Santa Cruz Hightower: four days of ~35 kms of riding per day. Long days make for great testing, especially contact points like pedals and shoes (I have been testing these with the Northwave Explorer GTX, review coming soon). And yeah, I brought backup in case it didn’t go well, and yeah, after day one I threatened to pull out the backup SPDs. The trails there just begged for an outrigger from time to time. Dusty, flat or or off-camber, or occasionally steep and loose – when I encounter turns like that on a trail I’m riding blind, Imagonnatossafootout. Thing is, I still wasn’t used to the extra float and wider disengagement angle of the Mallets, so I often found myself struggling to get my foot out in time. Then I would search a little bit for the contact when trying to re-engage. The latter issue is to be expected and I wasn’t as choked about it. The former sucked a little bit.

NSMB_SCB16_Hightower_Riding_Perkin

Once I started to jive with the Mallet E’s mechanism and feel, it all started to come together. Photo: Gary Perkin

I refused to give in. Day two went a little better. Clipping in was coming more easily, becoming almost natural. And in case I tried to clip in, raise my seat and have a drink all at once, the Mallet E’s wider platform was just fine for 5 or 10 unclipped pedal strokes, thank you very much. By day 3, I realized I quite liked them. Clipping in still felt softer than with SPDs (soft thunk vs. a hard click), but engagement was well-defined and predictable. It wasn’t until day 4 that I executed a good foot-out-to-drift-to-re-clip, but that was satisfying AF.

crankbrothers_mallet_1

The Mallet E’s body is 12% smaller than the Mallet DH, but that helps with clearance in tight spots. Look at all the machining and detail – Crank Bros hallmarks. Photo: Cam McRae

Since Chile, it’s been mostly peaches. We’ve had incredible amounts of rain and snow this winter, so the trails are sloppy and normally I’d be knocking shoes off on cranks each time we set off again. Not so with the Mallets – they engage in mud and snow like a man overboard in sharky waters latching on to a life ring. I have still been caught out on a few technical climbs, in mud, when I lost traction, needed an unclip and toppled sideways. Yep. Felt like learning on clipless all over again. But I was riding solo and no one saw it so it doesn’t really count.

Going over photos from the trip I came across not one but two of Cedric (that Cedric) going at FF speed, getting ready to unclip on his way into a corner…and it looked like his ankle was about to be dislocated. But the thing is he’s been riding Crank Bros pedals for years, and he’s just used to the extra force you need to exert to get that foot loose. For downhillers or those that ride with lots of body english, it makes a lot of sense. And I have to concede that I haven’t had a single accidental disengagement, either due to smacking my pedal off a rock at an oblique angle or just twisting my foot out while working the bike.

The final test will be to see how they hold up after more time. Crank Bros have added an additional lip seal to help protect the inboard bushing, and an Enduro bearing (the brand, not the contrived riding style) holds down the outboard fort. I’ll update this review with a durability report after I’ve put more time into them.

Crank_Bros_Mallet_E_internals

1 – Enduro cartridge bearing handles outboard duty. 2 – An Igus bushing. 3 – New double-lip seal system is featured on all Crank Bros pedals in 2016.

If you’re the type that likes to dig into materials and spec, here it is:
spindle material: forged scm 435 chromoly steel
body material: 6061-T6 aluminum
wing material: 17-4PH stainless
spring material: 300 series stainless steel
release angle: 15° / 20°
q-factor: 52mm
inner bearing type: igus LL-glide bearing
outer bearing type: enduro cartridge bearing
adjustable pins: 6 per side for grip
endcap: hex alloy
cleat: premium brass cleats with shims included
weight: 419g per pair
warranty: 5 years
CrankBrothersMallet_NSMB_KYamamura-1

One more look. Photo: Kaz Yamamura

More details about the Crank Brothers Mallet E pedals can be found on their site. They retail for $165 US but I’ve seen them for $165 in Canadian dollars as well.


Do you crank, bro?

Comments

jackson-lui
0
Jackson Lui  - Feb. 24, 2016, 8:22 p.m.

How would you compare this to the latest XTR Trail SPD offering in terms of being able to dab quickly which happens more on techy climbs?

Reply

andrew-tamura
0
Andrew Tamura  - Feb. 27, 2016, 12:16 a.m.

I switched to the mallet E from xtr trail and you can still unclip fairly fast but just takes a little more umph into it. I still have my xtr trails but I am loving the extra platform contact. It's night and day compared to shimano

Reply

jacksonlui
0
jack  - Feb. 27, 2016, 9:06 a.m.

Thx. I'll have to give it a shot at the end of this year. I just got my xtr pedals. Tech uphills are very sketchy with clipless. It's hard to get out and dab. I miss the feel ofy platforms and the mallet would be perfect except I think I'll need to remove the pins or lower them a lot. I don't like that it's 420g though. Pretty heavy by clipless standards.

Reply

rachid-nayel
0
Rachid Nayel  - Feb. 22, 2016, 1:25 p.m.

Pete,

Did you experience any corrosion at the spindle like the reviewer on Pinkbike did?

Reply

pete@nsmb.com
0
Pete Roggeman  - Feb. 22, 2016, 1:41 p.m.

Hadn't felt compelled to pull them off yet, since they're still spinning flawlessly. I will do so and report back.

Reply

0
t.odd  - Feb. 22, 2016, 9:25 a.m.

I could never get used to the inconsistent feel of the retention/release of CB pedals, then there was the whole random self destruct feature…

Reply

pete@nsmb.com
0
Pete Roggeman  - Feb. 22, 2016, 9:50 a.m.

It took me awhile as well, but they feel consistent now. It's definitely a bit softer, probably due to the brass cleats, and I think that's a big part of it.

Reply

0
t.odd  - Feb. 22, 2016, 9:58 a.m.

those brass cleats were/are the worst, they wear out so fast.

Reply

extraspecialandbitter
0
ExtraSpecialandBitter  - Feb. 22, 2016, 10:08 a.m.

The brass cleats do wear out quite quickly, especially if you are doing a lot of hike a bike. Be sure to replace them before they get bad or else you'll pre-release at the worst possible time… when you're enduro-ing hard (you crusty old fucker) 😀
Love it.

Reply

Please log in to leave a comment.

Trending on NSMB